Review – Steel


by Carrie Vaughn

A YA book with a heroine who figures things out fairly quickly (yay!) though she does do a few dumb things, she also knows how to fence and sort of randomly gets sucked back in time to hang out with pirates.

Jill wants to get back home to her time, especially because she hasn’t been so nice to her parents, but she has made some good friends among the pirates and has a little crush developing as well.  It is sweet.

The pirates are people, a few are caricatures, but not all.  Some are quite real feeling.

“If I don’t understand, it’s because, you see – I’m sure you’ve seen – that most of us don’t have anything to go back for. This is all the family we have, and all the world we need. Heaven and hell together.” (pg 228)

Things are romanticized a little bit. Yo ho, yo ho… and there are female pirates, plus Vaughn assembled a bunch of the big names in one tavern (she admits it’s not historically possible, but she couldn’t resist).  So we even catch a glimpse of Blackbeard.  Yaaaar!

“You still don’t understand, do you? It’s not about what happens. We may all be dead next week, eh? It’s about what you’ve got now. The wind and the sea. A bottle of rum and a ship of your own. Don’t think about what happens next.”

But you get a decent idea of what it might be like to live on a ship amongst pirates.  Though pretty much the Disneyfied version.  It is funny, while reading this I realized that a lot of YA has characters that are unhappy, think their parents are stupid and basically hate their lives UNTIL they are sucked back in time or kidnapped or something that forces them to work, barely keep themselves alive and scrape by so that they realize their parents were keeping them safe and cushy in the lap of luxury.  This book is no different.  In fact, she mentions how she now knows where the term “back breaking labor” comes from.

There is a tiny paranormal voodoo element (hello, sucked back in time) and a wonderful growing up story line full of self-realization and growth and a few sword fights.  It is great.  I enjoyed it.  I would LOVE it if they made a movie out of this book.  It would be a lot scarier visually and a good swashbuckling adventure.  It was easy peasy and fun, 3.5 steel stars washed up in the tide, rusted and flaking from years in the ocean.

About ocdreader

I love to read! I always have a book or four going, I have more books in my to-be-read pile than I can read in a year and yet I continue to haunt the bookstores. I have a problem, but I somehow soldier on. I enjoy talking books, so pass on your recommendations and thoughts - I would love to hear them.
This entry was posted in Embarrassment of Riches, Review, YA and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

8 Responses to Review – Steel

  1. I have not read a priate book in a long time. And never a YA one. Though much is romanticized, I really like the sound of this one. i like pirates. 🙂

  2. diannegray says:

    Pirates and voodoo – great mix! 😀

  3. Sara says:

    This sounds like a lot of fun!

  4. Love your star rating. Almost as romantic as the book sounds!

    • ocdreader says:

      Thank you so much! It relates, so that makes sense.

      Some of the fun star ratings jump to me, others don’t so easily and it is such a bummer to not find the perfect visual before I post, oh well, I gotta let it go sometimes 🙂

  5. Rohan 7 Things says:

    That sounds like fun! Pirates are always good value 🙂 I like your review style too, I can tell you are a “glass half full” kind of person, preferring to focus on the good stuff 🙂

    I love that cover too! Thanks for sharing, all the best.


  6. beckyday6 says:

    Oooooh I LOVE the front cover!

Don't be shy!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s